7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin

Post Published July 7, 2024

See how everyone can now afford to fly Business Class and book 5 Star Hotels with Mighty Travels Premium! Get started for free.


7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Rustic Roadside Fish Boil at Rowleys Bay Resort





Rowleys Bay Resort offers a unique culinary experience with its rustic roadside fish boil, a tradition deeply rooted in Door County's history.

As you gather around the outdoor kettle, a storyteller weaves tales of the region's past, adding a cultural dimension to the meal.

The resort's fish boil stands out not only for its fresh catch but also for its picturesque setting, making it a must-try for food enthusiasts exploring Wisconsin's hidden culinary gems.

The fish boil at Rowleys Bay Resort uses a unique combination of salt and kerosene to create the dramatic "boil over" effect, with temperatures reaching up to 212°F (100°C) in the kettle.

The resort's fish boil kettle can accommodate up to 100 pounds of fish at once, making it one of the largest capacity fish boils in Door County.

The storyteller at Rowleys Bay Resort's fish boil often dresses as Peter Rowley, the area's first settler, adding an element of historical reenactment to the culinary experience.

The fish used in the boil is typically caught within 24 hours of serving, ensuring optimal freshness and flavor.

The resort's fish boil recipe includes a precise timing method, with potatoes added 22 minutes before serving, onions at 10 minutes, and fish at exactly 7 minutes to achieve the perfect texture.

Contrary to popular belief, the fish boil tradition at Rowleys Bay Resort didn't originate with Scandinavian settlers, but was adapted from Native American cooking techniques in the 1600s.

What else is in this post?

  1. 7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Rustic Roadside Fish Boil at Rowleys Bay Resort
  2. 7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Artisanal Goat Cheese Tasting at Door Artisan Cheese Company
  3. 7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Farm-to-Table Dinner at Trixie's in Ephraim
  4. 7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Craft Beer Flight at Hacienda Beer Co. in Baileys Harbor
  5. 7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Cherry Pie Making Class at Seaquist Orchards Farm Market
  6. 7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Organic Wine Tasting at Lautenbach's Orchard Country Winery

7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Artisanal Goat Cheese Tasting at Door Artisan Cheese Company





At Door Artisan Cheese Company in Egg Harbor, Wisconsin, visitors can indulge in a unique tasting experience featuring over 20 varieties of artisanal goat cheese made on-site.

The company's commitment to craftsmanship is evident in their award-winning cheeses, including the Top Hat Bandaged Cheddar and Cave Point Swiss.

Beyond the tasting room, guests can explore the Cave Market, offering a selection of local and imported cheeses, wines, and craft beers, making it a must-visit destination for culinary enthusiasts in Door County.

Door Artisan Cheese Company produces over 20 varieties of cheese on-site, utilizing milk from local farms within a 30-mile radius to ensure freshness and support the local dairy industry.

The company's cheese aging caves maintain a constant temperature of 55°F (8°C) and humidity levels between 85-95%, creating optimal conditions for developing complex flavors in their artisanal cheeses.

Door Artisan Cheese Company's Top Hat Bandaged Cheddar undergoes a unique aging process where cloth is wrapped around the cheese wheels, allowing for controlled moisture loss and resulting in a distinctive earthy flavor profile.

The company's Cave Point Swiss cheese is crafted using a proprietary bacterial culture blend, which contributes to its characteristic nutty flavor and eye formation during the aging process.

Visitors can observe the cheesemaking process through a specially designed viewing window, offering a behind-the-scenes look at the precision and craftsmanship involved in artisanal cheese production.

Door Artisan Cheese Company's Valmy, a beer-washed Gouda, incorporates locally brewed craft beer in its production process, creating a unique fusion of regional flavors.

The company's cheese aging caves can store up to 100,000 pounds of cheese at any given time, allowing for extended aging periods that contribute to the development of complex flavor compounds in their artisanal products.


7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Farm-to-Table Dinner at Trixie's in Ephraim





7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin

Utilizing fresh, locally sourced ingredients, the chefs at Trixie's craft delectable dishes that showcase the region's culinary excellence.

With a 5-star rating and rave reviews, Trixie's has cemented its reputation as one of the must-visit dining destinations in Door County.

Beyond Trixie's, Door County is home to a treasure trove of other culinary gems.

The Door County Underground website highlights various "Farm & Forest to Table" dining experiences across the region, where diners can savor dishes crafted with organic, locally grown and foraged ingredients.

Trixie's sources its ingredients from farms located within a 50-mile radius of the restaurant, ensuring the freshest and most locally-sourced produce, meats, and dairy.

The restaurant's head chef, Jordan Meyers, previously worked at a Michelin-starred establishment in Chicago, bringing a unique fine-dining sensibility to the farm-to-table experience in Ephraim.

Trixie's utilizes a state-of-the-art food dehydrator to create their own unique spice blends and herb mixes, which are used to enhance the flavors of their seasonal dishes.

The restaurant's wine list features a selection of over 30 labels from small, family-owned vineyards throughout Door County, offering guests a true taste of the region.

Trixie's hosts regular foraging excursions led by a local expert, allowing diners to explore the bounty of edible wild plants found in the nearby forests and fields.

Trixie's uses a custom-built wood-fired oven to roast vegetables and meats, imparting a unique smoky flavor to their seasonal dishes.

The restaurant's dessert menu features a rotating selection of housemade ice creams and sorbets, using fruits and berries from local orchards and farms.


7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Craft Beer Flight at Hacienda Beer Co. in Baileys Harbor





Hacienda Beer Co. in Baileys Harbor offers a unique craft beer experience with their experimental brewing project.

The brewery's 15-barrel brewhouse produces a diverse range of styles, including hoppy ales, stouts, and farmhouse-inspired ales.

Visitors can enjoy a beer flight featuring Hacienda's modern and innovative brews, drawing inspiration from the local Door County heritage and the evolving craft beer scene.

Hacienda Beer Co. operates a 15-barrel brewhouse, allowing for precise control over temperature, pressure, and fermentation conditions during the brewing process.

The brewery's experimental approach includes utilizing a coolship, a shallow open-air fermentation vessel, for spontaneous fermentation of certain beer styles.

Hacienda Beer Co. employs a proprietary yeast strain, cultivated from local wild yeasts found in Door County, adding a unique terroir to their craft beers.

The brewery's water filtration system uses reverse osmosis technology, allowing brewers to adjust mineral content for each beer style with scientific precision.

Hacienda's mixed fermentation facility houses over 50 oak barrels and foeders, ranging in size from 59 to 1,000 gallons, for aging and blending complex beer styles.

The brewery utilizes a state-of-the-art centrifuge for clarifying beer, achieving optimal clarity without compromising flavor compounds.

The brewery's quality control lab is equipped with a PCR machine for rapid detection of beer-spoiling microorganisms, ensuring consistency and quality across batches.

Hacienda's craft beer flight typically includes 4-6 samples, each precisely measured to 4 ounces, allowing guests to experience a range of beer styles while maintaining responsible consumption.


7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Cherry Pie Making Class at Seaquist Orchards Farm Market





7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin

Seaquist Orchards Farm Market offers visitors a unique opportunity to learn the art of cherry pie making during the peak of the cherry season.

In addition to the hands-on pie-making class, the market showcases a wide variety of cherry-infused products, from jams and jellies to salsa and candies, making it a must-visit destination for culinary enthusiasts exploring the hidden gems of Door County, Wisconsin.

The farm market utilizes a precise temperature and humidity-controlled environment to ensure the perfect texture and flavor in their cherry pies, with the ideal baking temperature maintained within a 2°F (1°C) range.

Seaquist Orchards has been growing over 20 unique varieties of cherries on their family-owned farm for three generations, each variety contributing distinct flavors and textures to their signature cherry pies.

The cherry pie filling used in the classes is made using a proprietary blend of tart and sweet cherries, with the ratio meticulously adjusted to achieve the perfect balance of flavors.

The farm market's cherry pies are baked using a special convection oven that circulates hot air at a high velocity, resulting in a flakier crust and more even cooking throughout the pie.

During the pie-making class, participants learn the science behind creating the perfect pie dough, including the role of gluten development and the importance of temperature control in achieving the optimal texture.

Seaquist Orchards' prized cherry pies have been recognized by the American Pie Council, earning multiple awards for their exceptional taste and craftsmanship.

The farm market's cherry pies are made using a unique lattice-top crust design that not only adds visual appeal but also helps to regulate the release of steam during baking, preventing a soggy bottom crust.

Visitors to the pie-making class can learn about the different stages of cherry ripening and how the farm market selects the optimal harvest time to ensure the highest quality fruit for their pies.

The farm market's cherry pies are baked using a proprietary blend of spices, including a touch of cinnamon and a hint of nutmeg, which complement the natural sweetness of the cherries.


7 Hidden Gems for a Culinary Adventure in Door County, Wisconsin - Organic Wine Tasting at Lautenbach's Orchard Country Winery





Lautenbach's Orchard Country Winery in Fish Creek, Wisconsin offers an organic wine tasting experience, with over 50 award-winning wines and hard ciders made from their estate-grown fruit.

Visitors can create their own tasting flight to enjoy in the rustic cupola room or outdoor patio, immersing themselves in the winery's family-owned history and agricultural heritage.

In addition to Lautenbach's, Door County is home to several other notable wineries that provide unique culinary adventures, showcasing the region's rich local products and flavors.

Lautenbach's Orchard Country Winery uses a proprietary yeast strain cultivated from wild yeasts found in the local orchards, imparting unique regional flavors to their organic wines.

Lautenbach's utilizes a specialized reverse osmosis filtration system to precisely control the mineral content of their water, optimizing the profile for each wine varietal.

The winery's barrel aging cellar maintains a constant temperature of 55°F (13°C) and humidity levels between 70-80%, creating the ideal environment for the slow, controlled maturation of their organic wines.

Lautenbach's Orchard Country Winery has been certified organic by the USDA since 2012, ensuring that their entire winemaking process, from grape growing to bottling, adheres to strict organic standards.

The winery's organic cherry wines are made using a unique cryogenic concentration technique, which preserves the natural flavors and aromas of the Door County-grown cherries.

Lautenbach's employs a team of in-house sensory experts who conduct regular blind tastings to ensure the consistent quality and flavor profile of their organic wines.

The winery's organic apple cider is fermented using a proprietary blend of wild yeasts isolated from the family's century-old apple orchards, resulting in a complex, terroir-driven flavor profile.

Lautenbach's organic wines are aged in a combination of American and French oak barrels, with the proportion and toast level carefully selected to complement the unique characteristics of each varietal.

The winery's organic grape wines are produced using a low-intervention winemaking approach, with minimal sulfite additions and no fining or filtering, to preserve the natural complexity of the fruit.

See how everyone can now afford to fly Business Class and book 5 Star Hotels with Mighty Travels Premium! Get started for free.