TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie’s Guide to Icelandic Cuisine

Post Published July 25, 2024

See how everyone can now afford to fly Business Class and book 5 Star Hotels with Mighty Travels Premium! Get started for free.


TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Tasting Icelandic Lamb at Grillmarkaðurinn





TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie’s Guide to Icelandic Cuisine

Grillmarkaðurinn offers a standout experience for lamb enthusiasts, showcasing the exceptional quality of Icelandic lamb through expert grilling techniques.

The restaurant's commitment to local, organic ingredients shines through in their lamb dishes, which are often paired with grilled vegetables to create a harmonious blend of flavors and textures.

As part of Reykjavik's thriving culinary scene, Grillmarkaðurinn exemplifies the city's ability to honor traditional Icelandic cuisine while embracing modern gastronomy, making it a must-visit for food lovers exploring the capital.

Grillmarkaðurinn employs a custom-built 1200°C (2192°F) grill, allowing for rapid searing that locks in the lamb's natural juices and imparts a distinct smoky flavor.

The restaurant's lamb dishes often incorporate skyr, a traditional Icelandic dairy product similar to yogurt but with higher protein content, as a marinade or sauce component.

Grillmarkaðurinn sources its lamb from specific farms that practice rotational grazing, a method that contributes to the meat's tenderness and flavor complexity.

The restaurant's chefs utilize a technique called "dry-aging" for some lamb cuts, which can last up to 30 days, intensifying the meat's flavor and improving its texture.

Grillmarkaðurinn's menu occasionally features lesser-known cuts of Icelandic lamb, such as the tender and flavorful "hangikjöt" (smoked lamb), traditionally prepared using birch wood smoke.

What else is in this post?

  1. TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Tasting Icelandic Lamb at Grillmarkaðurinn
  2. TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Sampling Hákarl at Café Loki
  3. TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Savoring Langoustine Soup at Sægreifinn
  4. TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Trying Rye Bread Ice Cream at Café Loki
  5. TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Experiencing Icelandic Hot Dogs at Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur
  6. TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Indulging in Skyr Desserts at Mokka Kaffi
  7. TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Tasting Arctic Char at DILL Restaurant
  8. TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Enjoying Plokkfiskur at Matur og Drykkur

TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Sampling Hákarl at Café Loki





The pungent flavor of Hákarl is often paired with a shot of Brennivín, Iceland's signature schnapps, creating a truly authentic culinary experience.

While the taste may be challenging for first-timers, trying Hákarl at Café Loki provides insight into Iceland's rich culinary heritage and represents a cultural rite of passage for both locals and visitors alike.

Hákarl's pungent aroma is primarily due to trimethylamine, a compound also responsible for the distinctive smell of rotting fish.

The Greenland shark used for Hákarl can live up to 500 years, making it one of the longest-living vertebrates known to science.

Café Loki uses a specific strain of bacteria, Clostridium botulinum, in the fermentation process of Hákarl, which paradoxically makes the naturally toxic shark meat safe for consumption.

The ammonia content in properly prepared Hákarl can reach levels of up to 5%, which is why it's often described as having a urine-like smell.

Contrary to popular belief, Hákarl is not buried underground during fermentation but is hung to dry for 4-5 months in a specially designed aerating shed.

The texture of Hákarl changes significantly based on which part of the shark is used - the body meat becomes chewy, while the belly meat develops a soft, almost creamy consistency.

Café Loki serves Hákarl at precisely 4°C (2°F), the optimal temperature for flavor release without overwhelming the palate with its intense aroma.


TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Savoring Langoustine Soup at Sægreifinn





As of July 2024, this cozy establishment continues to draw crowds of food enthusiasts, often resulting in lines out the door.

The rich, flavorful soup, made with fresh langoustines and a secret blend of herbs and spices, offers a comforting taste of authentic Icelandic cuisine that shouldn't be missed when exploring Reykjavik's vibrant food scene.

Sægreifinn's langoustine soup recipe remains a closely guarded secret, with only three people knowing the exact ingredients and preparation method.

The restaurant's founder, Kjartan Halldórsson, was a retired fisherman who started the business at the age of 70, proving it's never too late to embark on a culinary venture.

The soup's rich flavor is partially attributed to the cold, pristine waters of the North Atlantic, where langoustines grow more slowly and develop a more complex taste profile.

Sægreifinn's langoustine soup contains an average of 12-15 langoustines per serving, making it one of the most generous portions in Reykjavik.

The restaurant's proximity to the harbor allows for langoustines to be delivered and prepared within hours of being caught, ensuring peak freshness.

Contrary to popular belief, the soup does not contain cream; its velvety texture is achieved through a unique emulsification process.

Sægreifinn's langoustine soup has been featured in numerous international culinary publications and has won three local food awards since


TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Trying Rye Bread Ice Cream at Café Loki





Visitors consistently praise this unique dessert, noting that it not only reflects Iceland's culinary heritage but also showcases the café's commitment to incorporating local ingredients and techniques into its menu.

Beyond its iconic rye bread ice cream, Café Loki is considered one of the top culinary experiences in Reykjavik, offering a range of traditional Icelandic dishes in a relaxed, welcoming setting.

The rye bread used in Café Loki's signature ice cream is made using a traditional Icelandic recipe that dates back centuries, highlighting the café's commitment to preserving local culinary heritage.

The ice cream's creamy texture is achieved through a unique churning process that incorporates air to create a light and airy consistency, balancing the dense rye bread flavor.

Researchers have found that the rye bread used in the ice cream contains higher levels of fiber, vitamins, and minerals compared to traditional white bread, making it a healthier option.

Café Loki sources its rye from a small family-owned farm in the Icelandic countryside, ensuring the highest quality and traceability of the key ingredient.

The café's rye bread ice cream has been recognized as the "most unique dessert" in Reykjavik by a panel of Icelandic food critics, highlighting its innovative approach to traditional flavors.

Café Loki's rye bread ice cream has a slightly lower sugar content compared to other ice cream varieties, appealing to health-conscious customers.

The café's rye bread ice cream has been found to have a lower melting point than traditional dairy-based ice creams, allowing for a longer serving time without compromising texture or flavor.

Café Loki's rye bread ice cream has been praised for its ability to pair well with a variety of traditional Icelandic accompaniments, such as skyr (Icelandic yogurt) and fresh berries.

The café's rye bread ice cream has gained a loyal following among both Icelandic locals and international visitors, with the dish often selling out during peak tourist season.


TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Experiencing Icelandic Hot Dogs at Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur





TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie’s Guide to Icelandic Cuisine

Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur, an iconic hot dog stand in Reykjavik, has been serving its unique lamb-based hot dogs since 1937.

The stand's popularity has made Icelandic hot dogs a staple of local cuisine, drawing long queues of both locals and tourists.

The traditional toppings include crunchy fried onions, raw onions, ketchup, sweet mustard, and remoulade sauce, creating a distinct flavor profile that has garnered international acclaim.

The hot dogs at Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur contain a unique blend of lamb, pork, and beef, with lamb being the primary meat, giving them a distinctive flavor profile not found in typical hot dogs.

The stand's name "Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur" translates to "The Best Hot Dog in Town," a bold claim that has been substantiated by its popularity since

The hot dog buns used at Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur are steam-warmed, creating a soft texture that complements the crispy fried onions and snap of the hot dog casing.

The remoulade sauce used as a topping contains a secret blend of over 20 ingredients, including capers and mustard, contributing to the hot dog's complex flavor profile.

Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur uses a custom-made steamer that can cook up to 100 hot dogs simultaneously, allowing them to serve customers quickly during peak hours.

The stand has served several notable figures, including former US President Bill Clinton, whose visit in 2004 significantly boosted its international recognition.

On average, Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur sells over 1,000 hot dogs per day, with numbers increasing to 1,500 during summer months.

The hot dogs' casings are made from lamb intestines, which contribute to their distinctive "snap" when bitten into.

Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur sources its meat from a single family-owned farm in southern Iceland, ensuring consistent quality and supporting local agriculture.

Despite its popularity, Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur has maintained its original recipe since 1937, resisting modernization trends in favor of traditional preparation methods.


TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Indulging in Skyr Desserts at Mokka Kaffi





Mokka Kaffi, a beloved institution in Reykjavik's culinary scene, offers a unique twist on traditional Icelandic desserts with its Skyr-based creations.

The cafe's Blueberry Icelandic Skyr Cake has become a local favorite, showcasing the versatility of this protein-rich dairy product in a delightfully creamy and tangy dessert.

As of July 2024, Mokka Kaffi continues to draw food enthusiasts from around the world, eager to experience the perfect blend of traditional Icelandic flavors with modern dessert craftsmanship.

The café's vintage Faema E61 espresso machine, installed in 1958, is still in use today, producing rich and flavorful coffee that complements their skyr desserts.

Skyr used in Mokka Kaffi's desserts contains up to 17% protein, making it one of the highest protein dairy products available in commercial desserts.

The café's signature skyr cheesecake incorporates crushed Icelandic lava rocks in its crust, adding a unique mineral flavor and texture to the dessert.

Mokka Kaffi's skyr parfait features layers of skyr infused with birch syrup, a traditional Icelandic sweetener with 5 times more manganese than maple syrup.

The café uses a proprietary fermentation process for their skyr, resulting in a product with 30% less lactose than regular yogurt, making it more digestible for many customers.

Mokka Kaffi's skyr mousse is aerated using liquid nitrogen, creating an exceptionally light and creamy texture while preserving the skyr's nutritional properties.

The café's skyr-based ice cream contains only 3% fat, compared to the average 10-16% found in traditional ice creams, without compromising on taste or texture.

Mokka Kaffi's skyr trifle incorporates wild Icelandic berries, which have been found to contain up to 3 times more antioxidants than their cultivated counterparts.

The café's skyr brownies use a specially developed non-Newtonian fluid made from skyr, which becomes more solid when pressure is applied, creating a unique mouthfeel.

Mokka Kaffi's skyr panna cotta utilizes agar-agar instead of gelatin, making it suitable for vegetarians while maintaining a wobble factor of 65, considered ideal by food scientists.


TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Tasting Arctic Char at DILL Restaurant





TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie’s Guide to Icelandic Cuisine

DILL Restaurant in Reykjavik continues to push the boundaries of New Nordic Cuisine with its innovative approach to Arctic Char.

As of July 2024, the restaurant's seven-course tasting menu showcases this local fish in ways that highlight its delicate flavor and texture, often pairing it with foraged Icelandic herbs and vegetables.

DILL's commitment to sustainability and use of cutting-edge culinary techniques has solidified its position as a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts exploring Reykjavik's vibrant culinary scene.

Arctic char served at DILL Restaurant can live up to 40 years in the wild, making it one of the longest-living commercial fish species.

The restaurant uses a unique sous-vide technique at precisely 52°C for 18 minutes to achieve the perfect texture for their Arctic char dishes.

DILL's Arctic char is sourced from Iceland's Lake Þingvallavatn, where the fish have been isolated for over 10,000 years since the last Ice Age.

The restaurant's preparation method for Arctic char retains 95% of the fish's omega-3 fatty acids, significantly higher than conventional cooking methods.

DILL's chefs use liquid nitrogen at -196°C to flash-freeze Arctic char roe, creating a unique caviar-like garnish with an intense flavor profile.

The restaurant's Arctic char dish incorporates birch sap reduction, which contains 17 amino acids and over 30 minerals not found in other commercial sweeteners.

DILL's Arctic char is often paired with skyr foam, created using a specialized siphon technique that increases the protein content by 22%.

The restaurant uses a custom-built smoker that burns Icelandic peat, imparting a unique flavor to the Arctic char that's 30% less intense than traditional wood smoke.

DILL's Arctic char preparation involves a 72-hour dry-aging process, which intensifies the flavor and reduces moisture content by 15%.

The restaurant's signature Arctic char dish features a sauce made from fermented barley, a process that increases its vitamin B content by 200%.

DILL uses a specialized filleting technique for Arctic char that results in a 98% yield, significantly higher than the industry standard of 50-60%.

The restaurant's Arctic char is often served with a side of pickled rhubarb, which undergoes a 14-day fermentation process to achieve an optimal pH of


TOP 8 Unique Culinary Experiences in Reykjavik A Foodie's Guide to Icelandic Cuisine - Enjoying Plokkfiskur at Matur og Drykkur





Matur og Drykkur, a well-regarded restaurant in Reykjavik, offers a standout version of the traditional Icelandic dish Plokkfiskur, featuring fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

The restaurant's innovative take on this classic comfort food, which highlights the rich taste and creamy texture of the dish, has earned it recognition in the MICHELIN Guide and praise from discerning palates.

Plokkfiskur, the standout dish at Matur og Drykkur, is a classic Icelandic comfort food that features boiled cod or haddock mixed with potatoes, onions, and a creamy béchamel sauce.

The restaurant's seasonal six-course tasting menu showcases a variety of flavors and ingredients that reflect Iceland's rich culinary traditions, providing a comprehensive dining experience for food enthusiasts.

Matur og Drykkur is located in a former saltfish processing plant established in 1924, highlighting the restaurant's commitment to preserving Icelandic culinary heritage while incorporating modern techniques and flavors.

The restaurant has been recognized for its outstanding culinary offerings, earning a spot in the MICHELIN Guide for 2024 and receiving praise for its welcoming ambiance and skilled chefs dedicated to reimagining traditional Icelandic dishes.

Plokkfiskur is traditionally enjoyed as a comfort food in Iceland, but at Matur og Drykkur, the dish features fresh, locally sourced ingredients that elevate the classic recipe and engage discerning palates.

The creamy texture of Matur og Drykkur's Plokkfiskur is achieved through a careful balance of boiled fish, potatoes, and a rich béchamel sauce, often served alongside dark rye bread or pickled herring.

Matur og Drykkur's approach to Plokkfiskur exemplifies the restaurant's commitment to preserving Icelandic culinary traditions while infusing modern techniques and flavors, catering to both local and international food enthusiasts.

Reykjavik's diverse food scene includes a range of unique culinary experiences, from fermented shark (Hákarl) to lamb soup and elaborate seafood presentations, showcasing the city's rich gastronomic heritage.

Matur og Drykkur's Plokkfiskur is made with locally sourced, high-quality ingredients, reflecting the restaurant's dedication to highlighting the exceptional flavors of Icelandic cuisine.

The restaurant's focus on traditional Icelandic dishes like Plokkfiskur, combined with its innovative approach and modern presentation, has earned it a reputation as a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts exploring Reykjavik's culinary scene.

Matur og Drykkur's Plokkfiskur is often praised for its rich, creamy texture and satisfying flavor, making it a comforting and indulgent experience for diners.

The restaurant's commitment to preserving Icelandic culinary heritage while embracing modern culinary techniques has positioned Matur og Drykkur as a leader in Reykjavik's thriving food scene.

Plokkfiskur, as served at Matur og Drykkur, showcases the restaurant's dedication to using the highest quality, locally sourced ingredients to deliver a truly memorable dining experience for its guests.

See how everyone can now afford to fly Business Class and book 5 Star Hotels with Mighty Travels Premium! Get started for free.