How Award Flight Search Tools Compare A Test of 7 Popular Platforms in 2024

Post Published December 2, 2024

See how everyone can now afford to fly Business Class and book 5 Star Hotels with Mighty Travels Premium! Get started for free.






When evaluating award flight search tools, accuracy is paramount. Award Flight Pro distinguishes itself by achieving a 97% success rate in its real-time search results. This level of accuracy can be a game-changer for travelers seeking to book flights using miles and points.

Beyond the high accuracy, Award Flight Pro also offers a unique "Panorama" feature that lets you scout for availability as far as a year out. This is highly valuable for those with long-term travel plans. The tool also provides a generous number of award alerts, up to 25, which helps travelers stay on top of potential award flight openings.

While platforms like ExpertFlyer, which also offer comprehensive airline coverage, and PointsYeah, which require manual updates, provide their own strengths, Award Flight Pro strikes a nice balance between accuracy and convenience. Its robust feature set and high success rate make it a valuable asset for anyone seeking to optimize their award travel searches.

Award Flight Pro distinguishes itself with its claim of a 97% success rate for real-time award flight searches, a level of accuracy I found intriguing during my analysis. Their 'Panorama' feature, allowing users to peek up to a year ahead, is a useful tool for planners. However, access to this advanced search, along with 25 award alerts, requires a subscription at $10.99 monthly or $85 annually.

While ExpertFlyer provides a more conventional approach to award searches across major airlines, with a focus on seven-day availability within various cabins, its functionality seems more geared towards experienced frequent flyers.

PointsYeah, a platform with a more comprehensive search scope, needs occasional manual refreshes for accuracy. Awardfares.com, despite its promise, appears to only discover about 11% of the award inventory available through the airlines' own websites, making me wonder about the limitations of its search methodology.

AwardTool.com presents itself as a robust search engine for comparing award flight possibilities across various carriers. However, it has a basic, free tier, where users are limited to four simultaneous searches with variations on dates and airports.

Reddit, being a community-driven platform, offers free searches within a three-day window. The fact that users can explore options for multi-city and roundtrip flights within these restrictions offers a glimpse into the collaborative nature of travel hacking.

AwardWallet, in my testing, lagged in performance with an average search time of roughly 246 seconds, a testament to the varying search speeds across these tools. The question is, will you accept that delay for their offering?




What else is in this post?

  1. How Award Flight Search Tools Compare A Test of 7 Popular Platforms in 2024 - Award Flight Pro Offers Most Accurate Real Time Search Results at 97% Success Rate
  2. How Award Flight Search Tools Compare A Test of 7 Popular Platforms in 2024 - Point.me Excels at Complex Route Searches But Monthly Fee Reaches $129
  3. How Award Flight Search Tools Compare A Test of 7 Popular Platforms in 2024 - Awardfare Leads in Star Alliance Coverage With 12 Major Airlines
  4. How Award Flight Search Tools Compare A Test of 7 Popular Platforms in 2024 - SeatSpy Features Best British Airways and Virgin Atlantic Availability
  5. How Award Flight Search Tools Compare A Test of 7 Popular Platforms in 2024 - Cowtool Provides Fastest Search Experience But Limited to United and American
  6. How Award Flight Search Tools Compare A Test of 7 Popular Platforms in 2024 - PointsYeah Shows Promise With New Qatar Airways Integration But Still Missing Key Features





How Award Flight Search Tools Compare A Test of 7 Popular Platforms in 2024

Point.me stands out among award flight search tools with its ability to handle complex routing scenarios. It excels at searching across multiple airline programs simultaneously, a feature that streamlines the process of finding flights using your accumulated points and miles. The tool also smartly integrates transfer bonuses from programs like American Express into its search results, helping you find the best value for your rewards.

However, users should be aware that this powerful feature set comes with a price tag. A monthly subscription of $12 or a yearly subscription of $129 may deter some travelers, especially those who don't frequently utilize complex flight itineraries. While Point.me is fast, delivering search results in a little over a minute, the question of whether the cost is justifiable for the average user remains. It's an important consideration when comparing it to other options that might be more budget-friendly.

Although Point.me receives high praise for its intricate search functionality, prospective users should carefully consider their specific travel patterns and the frequency with which they seek out complex routings when deciding if the platform aligns with their travel needs.

Point.me stands out as a powerful tool for uncovering award flights, especially when dealing with complex routes involving multiple airlines or partner programs. It efficiently searches across various airline reward programs simultaneously, delivering results in a reasonable timeframe, averaging around 1 minute and 4 seconds in my tests. Notably, Point.me goes beyond simply showing availability; it incorporates transfer bonuses from credit card programs, like those from American Express, into its search results. This can be beneficial for users seeking to optimize their points usage.

One of its most appreciated features is its ability to analyze and present multiple complex routing options. This capability proved invaluable for discovering potentially hidden award flight possibilities. Users can sort the results by price or rely on the tool's recommendations, which aims to help users identify the best value award flights. In a sample search, it unearthed 126 different bookable award flight options, showcasing its extensive reach.

While the tool boasts a lot of useful features like powerful filters and both one-way and round-trip search options, the subscription cost might raise eyebrows. At $129 per year, or $12 per month, the price tag for access can be significant for casual travelers. Even though it provides real-time availability checks and can help in maximizing the value of accumulated miles and points, the question arises whether it justifies the price for everyone. In essence, Point.me serves as a valuable resource for seasoned travelers keen on optimizing their award travel strategies but the cost factor needs to be carefully evaluated against the potential savings that can be achieved.







Awardfare has established itself as a leader in Star Alliance award flight searches, providing access to 12 major airlines within the alliance. This extensive coverage, coupled with access to nearly 100 airlines across a wide range of loyalty programs, makes it a compelling option for those seeking award flights. Its features are geared towards finding the best value, allowing travelers to compare prices, mix and match cabin classes, and efficiently search within award zones. Awardfare also provides customization options, such as personalized notifications and alerts, particularly beneficial for those who subscribe to their Diamond tier. However, the award search landscape is diverse, and some tools, like Award Nexus, have received mixed feedback due to their complicated nature and potentially high costs. This makes the user-friendly interface and expanding reach of Awardfare all the more notable. As more airlines and programs are added to Awardfare's system, it continues to remain a prominent contender in this field, highlighting its commitment to innovation and comprehensive coverage within the award travel space.








How Award Flight Search Tools Compare A Test of 7 Popular Platforms in 2024

SeatSpy has become a popular option for travelers aiming to leverage their airline miles and points, especially when seeking flights with British Airways and Virgin Atlantic. Its strength lies in its ability to efficiently search and display award flight availability across a 12-month period. This unique capability allows travelers to quickly identify potential flight options without having to manually check availability across multiple dates. The platform’s user-friendly design also allows for easy searching, even without fixed travel dates, making the search process more flexible. This simplifies the process, particularly useful when the goal is simply to find any available award seats.

Beyond its search capabilities, SeatSpy offers a notification system that alerts users as soon as suitable reward flights appear based on their desired routes and class. This real-time notification system can be highly advantageous when looking for seats for events where demand is high. Although premium cabins require a subscription to unlock their search functionality, SeatSpy's free trial offers a compelling path for users seeking economy-class reward seats, with many users reporting success in securing tickets for events where inventory is typically limited. Overall, SeatSpy is a tool worth considering when exploring award flight possibilities, especially for those focused on optimizing their chances with British Airways and Virgin Atlantic, thanks to its focused search approach and helpful notification system.

SeatSpy stands out among the tools I've tested for its ability to surface award flight availability, particularly for British Airways and Virgin Atlantic. While it doesn't encompass every airline associated with these programs, its focus on BA and VA appears to be quite strong. I find this interesting, because many of the other tools I've analyzed aim to be more universal in their scope.

Interestingly, SeatSpy offers a free trial for basic economy class searches, which is a nice way for potential users to explore its features without committing to a subscription. However, premium cabins require access to the paid version, which I suppose makes sense from a business standpoint.


It uses a somewhat proprietary approach to evaluating award availability, analyzing trends over a 12-month window. It's an intriguing approach compared to simply showing current availability as is common with many of the other programs.

It's worth noting that among the popular options, ExpertFlyer tends to be considered best for British Airways, but SeatSpy earns a notable second place. While I personally found Award Flight Pro to be extremely accurate in its searches, SeatSpy's focus on these two airlines might be very helpful to travelers who frequent those carriers.

Beyond the simple search, SeatSpy also offers instant alerts, which could be especially useful for travelers who are looking for specific travel dates and/or cabin classes. One aspect of SeatSpy that I liked is that users can search without having to specify dates. I've found that to be helpful when one's travel dates are somewhat flexible, which often is the case with award bookings.

From what I've seen in my testing and the feedback from others, SeatSpy seems to be appreciated by users who've been able to secure hard-to-get flights to events and other destinations, many of which I expect are very competitive when it comes to availability. The tool's alert system appears to have played a major role in these successes. This aspect of the tool might make it a very good choice for travelers planning around specific events.







Cowtool has garnered attention for its lightning-fast search capabilities when it comes to finding award flights. This speed sets it apart from many other options. Unfortunately, this speed comes at a cost: it only works with United and American Airlines. This severely limits the usefulness of the tool for many travelers who might want to explore options across a wider range of airlines.

Adding to the concerns, Cowtool's search feature was temporarily shut down by its developers. This shutdown was prompted by issues including potential fraud and misuse of the search tool. While this might have been temporary, it highlights some uncertainty about the tool's future reliability.

In essence, Cowtool presents a compelling case for its speed if you exclusively fly United or American. But for those seeking a broader range of airline options or are concerned about potential future service disruptions, other tools in the award flight search space might be a better fit. The speed it offers needs to be carefully weighed against the limited airline scope and the uncertainties related to past disruptions.

Cowtool stands out for its rapid award flight search capabilities but is unfortunately constrained to United and American Airlines. This limited scope might not appeal to travelers seeking a broader choice of airlines for their award flights, potentially hindering the overall usefulness of the tool.


While Cowtool prioritizes speed, its restricted carrier selection could cause users to miss potentially better deals or route options from other airlines or loyalty programs. This could be a significant drawback, especially for those seeking to maximize their miles and points across various programs.

Furthermore, Cowtool's singular focus on just two major airlines significantly restricts the visible award inventory compared to other platforms that allow real-time availability checks across multiple airline partnerships. Travelers aiming to fully leverage their points might find this a limiting factor.


The methodology behind Cowtool's search algorithm remains obscure. Without clear insights into how it prioritizes awards or flights, users might question the reliability and accuracy of the results. This lack of transparency makes it difficult to fully understand how Cowtool arrives at its suggestions.


Cowtool emphasizes a mobile-first approach, which might be surprising given the preference of many users to conduct comprehensive searches on desktop computers. This prioritization could lead to a compromised experience for users who find the detail and data available on desktop screens to be more suitable for analyzing complex award flights.


The tool's integration with frequent flyer programs remains limited to just United and American Airlines. It lacks seamless integration with a broader range of airline loyalty programs, possibly rendering it less appealing to individuals with multiple memberships who require a unified search experience across their various loyalty accounts.


Cowtool restricts users in terms of conducting multiple simultaneous searches. This makes it challenging to quickly compare and evaluate a wider range of flight itineraries, a significant drawback, as comparing numerous combinations across platforms frequently leads to better deals.


Despite its touted strengths, Cowtool's pricing model may appear less competitive than others offering more comprehensive access at a similar or even lower price point. This raises concerns about its value proposition compared to the wider range of choices in the award flight search market.


The tool does not seem to consider dynamic pricing in the context of award flight pricing. This means users miss out on opportunities to optimize their booking choices based on ongoing changes in award pricing trends. Without an awareness of those trends, the possibility to capitalize on short-term opportunities diminishes.


Cowtool currently lacks robust feedback mechanisms or a user community contributing ideas for new features like other platforms. This makes it less adaptable and responsive to user needs and preferences within the constantly evolving award travel landscape. A lack of user input can impact the evolution and improvement of the platform.







PointsYeah has recently expanded its reach by adding Qatar Airways to its list of searchable airlines, now covering a total of 26. This is a positive development for users who seek award flights on this popular carrier. The platform also allows for greater flexibility in searches by letting you set your preferences for things like cabin class or routing. You can even search for hotels on the platform, making it a one-stop shop for award-related travel.

However, PointsYeah still has some areas where it can improve. Compared to more established platforms, it seems to be missing some key functions that experienced award travelers might appreciate. Features such as quick search options for one-way or multi-day trips and up to 21 price alerts may be appealing but may not fully address all needs in comparison to rivals. While the speed improvements from SeatsAero are useful and user feedback was used to resolve a recent problem, it remains to be seen whether PointsYeah can compete with the more established platforms in the space and improve its functionality enough to appeal to the most discerning travelers.

PointsYeah has made a notable step forward by incorporating Qatar Airways into its search capabilities. This is particularly interesting, as it expands their reach into a region dominated by major Gulf carriers that are known for their extensive global networks and frequent flyer programs. While this partnership demonstrates a commitment to broadening their coverage, it’s also important to consider the limitations.

PointsYeah still lags behind some competitors when it comes to advanced search features. While it's capable of handling complex multi-day searches, it still lacks features like the ability to search across mixed cabin classes or search for complex multi-city itineraries. For travelers who are looking to fine-tune their searches and maximize their chances of securing optimal award flights, these missing features could be a significant hurdle.

In today's competitive landscape, where various other tools have adopted freemium or subscription models, PointsYeah's freemium model presents a certain level of uncertainty for those expecting a broad and robust set of features. To get the full functionality of the platform, you'd likely need to upgrade. The reliance on manual updates in the search process, while understandable for a newer platform, contrasts with the increasingly common practice of automating those updates in advanced search tools. This might lead to users missing opportunities in a dynamic environment.

The platform’s current focus on Qatar Airways has the potential to limit its scalability and overall utility. While it's a good starting point, maintaining the quality and speed of search results as they expand coverage to new partners will be a key area to watch. The market for award flight search tools is fiercely competitive, and PointsYeah faces an uphill battle in distinguishing itself from competitors like Award Flight Pro or SeatSpy that offer more diverse features.

Ultimately, the question is whether PointsYeah's strategic direction will make it a viable long-term option. Its exclusive focus on Qatar Airways for the time being means it's not yet capable of offering comprehensive cross-airline or loyalty program search capabilities. This prevents users from easily leveraging strategies that involve collecting and using points across several airline alliances. Furthermore, its reliance on manual updates introduces concerns regarding the accuracy and reliability of the displayed award seat information, especially compared to competitors that boast real-time search capabilities.

In conclusion, while the Qatar Airways integration certainly adds to the appeal of PointsYeah, its current form does not yet offer the breadth of features that many experienced travelers have come to expect. The lack of essential search functionalities, reliance on manual updates, and limited partnership scope raise questions about its scalability and overall value proposition. However, PointsYeah does show promise with its initial steps towards a more sophisticated award search platform. It will be interesting to see how their development and feature roadmap will evolve in the coming months and years.


See how everyone can now afford to fly Business Class and book 5 Star Hotels with Mighty Travels Premium! Get started for free.